Missing Gemaras.
Babli thus contains but one treatise each of the first and sixth orders; of the second, SheKalim (see above) is lacking; and there is no Talmud on 'Eduyot or Abot either in Babli or Yerushalmi. The fifth order of Babli contains neither Middot nor Kinnim, nor the third, fifth, sixth, and seventh chapters of Tamid. It is incorrect, however, to speak of missing portions of the Babylonian Talmud, since in all probability the sections which it omits were entirely disregarded in the final redaction of the work, and were consequently never committed to writing (for a divergent opinion see Weiss, "Dor," iii. 271). It will be shown further on that the mishnaic treatises lacking in Babli were subjects of study in the Babylonian academies.
Search Elijah Cups, Judaica, Jewish Jewelry and Jewish Books
Thursday, December 6, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment